Assessment deep dives

New York State Department of Civil Service assessments

United States (New York) · firefighter exam guide

The situational judgment section

“This section tests for the ability to identify appropriate and effective responses to work-related challenges.”

New York State Department of Civil ServiceFirefighter test guide

New York State Department of Civil Service · Undated, checked 11 November 2026

Effective responses to work challenges

Pick the response that solves the problem.

Example

“There may be several approaches that effectively (or ineffectively) address a given challenge.”

New York State Department of Civil ServiceFirefighter test guide

New York State Department of Civil Service · Undated, checked 11 November 2026

Several approaches can work

More than one option can be effective.

Example

“Kevin has not been performing well in a particular area, and the supervisor wants John to help Kevin develop his skills.”

New York State Department of Civil ServiceSample question

New York State Department of Civil Service · Undated, checked 11 November 2026

A colleague who needs help

Help a struggling colleague without blame.

Example

“Calling Kevin disrespectful will likely only aggravate Kevin more, and this response does not further the goal of helping Kevin develop his skills.”

New York State Department of Civil ServiceSample rationale

New York State Department of Civil Service · Undated, checked 11 November 2026

Why one option fails

Labels make it worse.

Example

“This response emphasizes cooperation and mutual benefit and keeps the focus on the ultimate goal of performing more effectively.”

New York State Department of Civil ServiceSample rationale

New York State Department of Civil Service · Undated, checked 11 November 2026

Why one option works

Focus on the shared goal.

Example

Last reviewed